Skip to main content

Upholding the Constitutional Right to Fair Hearing: A Landmark Judgment


In the  recent case of "First Option Motors Ltd. & Anor. vs. Ogun State Government & Ors"
the Court of Appeal delivered a significant judgment emphasizing the importance of the constitutional right to fair hearing. The case centered around the revocation of the appellants' land title without affording them an opportunity to present their case. This article explores the key principles discussed in the judgment and their implications for adhoc bodies tasked with determining individuals' rights.

The Principle of Fair Hearing:
The Court of Appeal reiterated that the right to fair hearing is a fundamental principle enshrined in the Nigerian Constitution. Section 36(1) of the 1999 Constitution guarantees that every person is entitled to a fair hearing within a reasonable time by a court or tribunal established by law. This principle applies not only to courts but also to adhoc bodies with the authority to determine individuals' rights.

The Obligation to Hear Parties:
The judgment emphasized that parties must be given the opportunity to present their case before their rights are affected. Denying a party the right to be heard not only violates the principles of fair hearing but also renders the entire proceedings null and void. The court cited various precedents that underscored the importance of hearing both sides of a dispute and the consequences of breaching this fundamental principle.
Adhoc Bodies and Fair Hearing:
The Court of Appeal clarified that adhoc bodies, such as commissions of inquiry, must also adhere to fair hearing rules. The fact that a body is established to conduct fact-finding does not exempt it from the obligation to observe fair hearing principles. The court held that any proceedings conducted in breach of fair hearing rights, regardless of how well-conducted they may be, would be rendered null and void.
Implications of the Judgment:
The judgment in *First Option Motors Ltd. & Anor. vs. Ogun State Government & Ors.* has significant implications for the protection of individuals' rights. It establishes that any decision or recommendation made without affording parties a fair hearing is fundamentally flawed and can be set aside. The breach of fair hearing has a profound effect on the proceedings and renders any subsequent actions based on such a breach null and void.

Conclusion:
The Court of Appeal's judgment in *First Option Motors Ltd. & Anor. vs. Ogun State Government & Ors.* serves as a landmark decision reaffirming the constitutional right to fair hearing. It highlights the obligation of adhoc bodies to observe fair

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

COVID 19 Is Still Causing Serious Pandemic Now ,The Number Of Affected Persons Within Two Days Is Outrageous.

COVID-19 UPDATES IN  NIGERIA NCDC releases Highlights on COVID 19 COVID-19 NIGERIA Friday 7:55 am 19 Jun 2020 Samples Tested On the 18th of June 2020, 745 new confirmed cases and 6 deaths were recorded in Nigeria No new state has reported a case in the last 24 hours. Till date, 18480 cases have been confirmed, 6307 cases have been discharged and 475 deaths have been recorded in 35 states and the Federal Capital Territory The 745 new cases are reported from 21 states- Lagos(280), Oyo(103), Ebonyi(72), FCT(60), Imo(46), Edo(34), Delta(33), Rivers(25), Kaduna(23), Ondo(16), Katsina(12), Kano(10), Bauchi(8), Borno(7), Kwara(5), Gombe(4), Sokoto(2), Enugu(2), Yobe(1), Osun(1), Nasarawa(1) Click here to read more NCDC ✔ @NCDCgov 745 new cases of # COVID19Nigeria ; Lagos-280 Oyo-103 Ebonyi-72 FCT-60 Imo-46 Edo-34 Delta-33 Rivers-25 Kaduna-23 Ondo-16 Katsina-12 Kano-10 Bauchi-8 Borno-7 Kwara-5 Gombe-4 Sokoto-2 Enugu-2 Yobe-1 Osun-1 Nasarawa-1 18,480 confirmed 6,307 discharged 4...

Otu oka-iwu Abuja endorses Mazi Afam Osigwe SAN as NBA Presidential Candidate in the 2024 NBA Election.

The Igbo Lawyers Group Comes Out in Support for Afam Osigwe as their tradition demands in Forthcoming NBA Election The umbrella organization of Igbo lawyers in Abuja, Otu Oka-iwu Abuja, has endorsed Mazi Afam Osigwe as its candidate for the forthcoming NBA presidential election. The President of Otu Oka-iwu Abuja made this announcement during a meeting with Igbo lawyers in Gwagwalada, highlighting Osigwe's dedication and contributions to the Igbo lawyers' association (Otu oka-iwu Abuja). The President emphasized the importance of supporting Osigwe at this critical moment, in line with the organization's tradition and values. The President highlighted the fact that the constitution of Otu oka-iwu Abuja was financed and printed by Mazi Afam Osigwe single-handedly, adding that it has been a longstanding norm to rally behind members of the association whenever they are contesting against non-members. In line with this principle, the publicity Secretary, Mrs. Bridge ...

Dr Princess Frank-Chukwuani, (Former chairman, NBA Abuja Branch) Congratulates High Chief Emeka Obegolu SAN on his inauguration as the 12th President of the Abuja Chamber of Commerce and Industry.

Dr. Princess Frank-Chukwuani, former chairman of the NBA Abuja Branch, expressed her elation and admiration for High chief Emeka Obegolu J.P, SAN as he was Inaugurated the 12th Abuja chamber of Commerce and Industry, President. For his leadership qualities and dedication to service.  She commended his vision and passion, believing that his tenure will bring positive change and growth to the Chamber.  Dr. Chukwuani's words of encouragement and well wishes reflect a deep respect and fondness for her dear brother and friend, High Chief Obegolu, known as Akajiugo 1 of Obeledu.              May he continue to soar to greater heights in his new role. In a congratulatory message made available to our media desk; Dr princess Frank Chukwani stated as follows;             Dr princess Frank Chukwani.        Former NBA Chairman, Abuja Branch. "I am elated by your auspicious Inauguration and assumption of ...

Shehu Sani: Former Senator Claims Shehu and Edu Would Have Survived Under Buhari's Administration

Former senator representing Kaduna Central, Shehu Sani, has recently stated that the suspended Minister of Humanitarian Affairs and Poverty Alleviation, Dr Betta Edu, and the Chief Executive Officer of the National Social Investment Programme Agency (NSIPA), Halima Shehu, would have likely survived suspension under former President Muhammadu Buhari's administration. In an interview on Trust Radio, Sani, who was once a member of the All Progressives Congress, expressed his belief that if the public outcry calling for Dr Edu's suspension had occurred during Buhari's tenure, it would have been disregarded and fallen on deaf ears. Sani commended President Bola Tinubu for taking decisive action in suspending Dr Edu and Shehu, stating that this move reflects the administration's responsiveness to public appeals. However, Sani emphasized the difference between Tinubu and Buhari, stating that Tinubu's willingness to take action against wrongdoing sets him apart....

The leadership of NBA Abuja Branch (Unity Bar) extends season's greetings to members of the branch and urges them to pay their Bar Practicing Fee via the BPF code: 004 for NBA Abuja Branch, using the NBA Digital App.

find other interesting articles via this click. Distinguished Learned Silks, Benchers and Colleagues,  Compliments of the Season!   The BPF code for NBA Abuja Branch is 004   Please be reminded that the Bar Practicing Fee (BPF) for the year 2024 shall become payable from the 1st of January, 2024 to 31st of March, 2024, in accordance with the provisions of Section 9(1) of the Legal Practitioners Act. As we usher in the new year, it is essential for all legal practitioners to be aware of their obligations and responsibilities. One such obligation is the payment of the Bar Practicing Fee (BPF), which is a requirement for all members of the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA). In an effort to streamline the payment process and enhance convenience for its members, the NBA has introduced the NBA Digital App: https://portal.nigerianbar.org.ng    https://apps.apple.com/ng/app/nba-digital-a Efficiency and Convenience: Gone are the days of queuing up at the NB...

The Election of Enugu State Speaker, Rt Hon Uche Ugwu, as the National Deputy Chairman, South-East Region of speakers of State legislatures, in the Conference of Speakers held in Abuja - A Testament of humility and credible Leadership.

In a remarkable turn of events,  Hon. Uche Ugwu, the Speaker of the Enugu State House of Assembly, emerged as the National Deputy Chairman for the South-East region in the Conference of Speakers of State Legislatures, Federal Republic of Nigeria, In an election held in Abuja on 16th September 2023.This significant achievement not only exemplifies Hon. Ugwu's exceptional leadership qualities but also serves as a testament to his unwavering commitment to serving the people of Enugu State and the larger Nigerian community. This article aims to shed light on the remarkable journey of Hon. Ugwu and the implications of his new position. A Leader Driven by Vision and Dedication: Hon. Uche Ugwu's journey in politics has been marked by sincerity, dedication, and deep-rooted values. Throughout his tenure as the deputy Speaker of Enugu State House of Assembly, during governor ifeanyi Ugwuanyi's administration. Rt Hon Ugwu has demonstrated a strong commitment to the welfare of his cons...

Italian news: I Did Not Mean To Be Offensive - Italian journalist Marika Fruscio Pleads With Nigerians After Post Knocking Osimhen

Italian journalist Marika Fruscio, in a social media post on Wednesday, has pleaded with Nigerians over her statement knocking Nigerian-born footballer Victor Osimhen. The Super Eagles striker had deleted Napoli-related posts following a now-deleted TikTok video shared by the club mocking his failed penalty kick against Bologna on Sunday. Osimhen's agent, Roberto Calenda, not long after, released a statement expressing the footballer's displeasure about the video, adding that he is considering legal action. "What happened today [Tuesday] on Napoli's official profile on the TikTok platform is not acceptable. "A video mocking Victor was first made public and then, but now belatedly, deleted.  "A serious fact that causes very serious damage to the player and adds to the treatment that the boy is suffering in the last period between media trials and fake news.  Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office UK and Nigeria news page access UK government  services ...

The Negative effects of screening Ministerial nominees by the Nigeria Senate without stating their portfolios?

Senate Transmits Names Of 45 Confirmed Ministerial Nominees To Presidency. Some of the nominees includes:  from the North-West are Badaru Abubakar from Jigawa State, Mariya Mahmoud (Kano), Abdullahi Tijjani Gwarzo (Kano), Ahmed Dangiwa (Katsina), Hannatu Musawa (Katsina), Dr. Yusuf Tanko Sununu (Kebbi), Atiku Bagudu (Kebbi), Bello Muhammad Goronyo (Sokoto) and Bello Matawalle from Zamfara State. There are several several negative effects of screening ministerial nominees by the Nigeria Senate without stating their portfolios: 1. Lack of specific scrutiny: When ministerial nominees are not assigned specific portfolios during the screening process, it becomes difficult for the Senate to thoroughly assess their suitability for the specific roles they will be assigned. This can result in a lack of focused questioning and evaluation, potentially leading to the appointment of ministers who may not be the best fit for their assigned portfolios. 2. Inefficient allocation of responsibilities: W...

Vetoed Bills: Legislative Lawyer, Dr. Jaja and ALDRAP to Hire Dr. Ajulo, SAN to File Lawsuit Against Rivers State House of Assembly.

  In a bid to seek clarification on the recent vetoed bills by the Rivers State House of Assembly, renowned legislative drafting lawyer, Dr. Tonye Jaja, and the Association of Legislative Drafting and Advocacy Practitioners (ALDRAP) have decided to hire the services of Dr. Ajulo, SAN. The lawsuit aims to determine whether the assembly has complied with the constitutional provisions regarding the vetoed bills.                         Dr. Ajulo, SAN. The Issues for determination: The lawsuit intends to address several key issues that have arisen from the vetoed bills. These issues include: 1. Compliance with Timeframe: The first issue to be determined is whether the Rivers State House of Assembly adhered to the constitutional provision that requires a 30-day period to elapse from when the bill was submitted to the governor. 2. Legislative Authority: The second issue revolves around whether a State Hou...

Governor Ifeanyi Ugwuanyi Takes Every Measure To Ensure The Safety Of The People Of Enugu Over the Sudden Rise Of Spread Of Covid 19 In The State.

Enugu constitutes medical committee on de-escalation of coronavirus. Gov. Ifeanyi Ugwuanyi Gov. Ifeanyi Ugwuanyi has approved the constitution of an ad-hoc Expert Medical Advisory Committee on urgent and effective measures for de-escalation of COVID-19 pandemic in Enugu State. Newsmen report that the setting up of the committee followed the recent spike of COVID-19 cases from 76 to 144 within few days in the state. The Secretary to the State Government, Prof. Simon Ortuanya, in a statement on Tuesday, said that the committee was set-up by Gov. Ugwuanyi as recommended by the state chapter of the Nigeria Medical Association (NMA). Ortuanya said that the committee would engage with leaders of various religious groups, market associations, professional associations, labour unions, National Union of Road Transport Workers, Association of Tricycle Riders Transport Union, Civil Society Organisations, the private sector and other relevant stakeholders. “The committee will recommend urgent and...